Right to resistance in the context of democratic processes

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.21564/2414-990x.129.52031

Keywords:

right to resistance, stability of constitutional order, democracy of participation, democratic process, nationwide referendum

Abstract

Problem setting. Right to resistance and especially right to rebellion should be considered as an element of constitutional order’s ensuring. It means the right of some Ukrainian citizen to realize civil disobedience as a resistance and a rebellion as to one kind of it.

Rebellion against the power is the result of absence of stage-by-stage mutual discussion and consensus between power and people. It means that the absence of past democratic practices could be the reason of power usurpation and human rights violations.

Recent research and publications analysis. Right of people to resistance and rebellion was considered by numerous scientists in the spheres of constitutional right, of political science and legal theory of past and modern times. Among them it could be named J. Lock, V.V. Rechitskij, S.Pogrebnjak etc.

Paper objective. The main aim of the article is to find out the essence of the right to resistance and rebellion as an element of constitutional order’s ensuring, to review reasons of it, its forms and their realizations in a modern democratic state.

Paper main body. In the article it is considered the direct and indirect form of the right’s realization. Directly the right to resistance takes is executed in the case of violations by bodies of a state power or in the case of citizen’s disagreement with their activity by means of unarmed meetings, campaigns and demonstrations, strikes for protection of their economic and social interests. One of the most democratic methods of resistance that has indirect character is a nationwide referendum against the solutions of a parliament. The alternative forms of resistance are civil hearings and people’s legislative initiatives, “people’s veto”, which can decrease the probability of a conflict aggravation.  

Conclusions. Only participation of each citizen in the process of state rule should to prevent human and civil rights violations, abuses of state authority that can have as a consequence the direct realization of a natural right of people to resistance to oppression.

 

Author Biography

К. О. Павшук, Yaroslav Mudryi National Law University

Candidate of Law Sciences, Assistant of Department of Constitutional Law Ukraine

References

Almond, G., Verba, S. (1992). Grazhdanskaja kul'tura i stabil'nost' demokratii. Polis «Politicheskie issledovanija», 4. Setevoj portal zhurnala «Polis». Available at: http://www.polisportal.ru/index.php?page_id=51&id=28

Barber, B. (2005). Syl'na demokratija: polityka uchasnyc'kogo typu. Demokratija: Antologija. Kyiv: Smoloskyp, 254–262.

Bobbio, N. (2005). Majbutnje demokratii'. Demokratija: Antologija. Kyiv: Smoloskyp, 105–119.

Konstitucija Jestonskoj Respubliki ot 28 ijunja 1992. Available at: http://www.president.ee/ru/republic-of-estonia/constitution-of-the-republic-of-estonia/index.html

Lokk, Dzh. Dva traktata o pravlenii. Jelektronnaja biblioteka «Grazhdanskoe obshhestvo». Available at: http://www.civisbook.ru/

Pavshuk, K. O. (2013). Do problemy provedennja konstytucijnogo i zakonodavchogo referendumiv v Ukrai'ni. Problemy zakonnosti. Kharkiv: Natcionalnii universitet «JuAU imeni Ja. Mudrogo», 124, 204–212.

Pogrebnjak, S. P., Uvarova, E. A. (2013). Soprotyvlenye ugnetenyju. Vosstanye. Revoljucyja (teoretyko-pravovoj analyz v svete doktryni prav cheloveka). Pravo i gromadjans'ke suspil'stvo, 2, 4–61.

Rechickij, V. V. (2012). Politicheskij predmet konstitucii. Kyiv: Duh і lіtera, 728.

Rechickij, V. V. (1998). Jesse o politike. Kharkivska pravozashhitnaja gruppa. Kharkiv: Folio, 112. (Prava ljudini, 5(37)). Prava ljudini v Ukrainі. Іnformacіjnij portal Harkіvs'koi pravozahisnoi grupi. Available at: http://library.khpg.org/index.php?id=1080686571

Rechyc'kyj, V. Dekil'ka mirkuvan' shhodo novogo zakonu pro referendum. Prava ljudyny v Ukrai'ni / Informacijnyj portal Harkivs'koi' pravozahysnoi' grupy. Available at: http://www.khpg.org/index.php?id=1355259554

Romanchuk, O. Pryrodne pravo. Ukrai'ns'ka pravda. Available at: http://www.pravda.com.ua/articles/2007/08/17/3271782/

Rotar, N. Ju. (2007). Uchast' gromadjan Ukrai'ny u cyklichnyh politychnyh procesah transformacijnogo periodu. Chernivetckii natcionalnii universitet im. Ju. Fed'kovycha. Chernivci, 39.

Chub, O. O., Dahova, I. I., Jevsjejev, O. P. et. al.; Barabash, Ju. G. (Ed.) (2013). Zagal'na harakterystyka form bezposeredn'oi' ta predstavnyc'koi' demokratii' v aspekti funkcionuvannja derzhavnoi' vlady v Ukrai'ni. Demokratychni zasady organizacii' i funkcionuvannja vyshhyh organiv derzhavnoi' vlady Ukrai'ny. Kharkiv: Pravo, Charpet 1, part II, 157–192.

Shapoval, V. (2005). Referendum jak forma bezposeredn'oi' demokratii'. Vybory ta demokratija, 3, 4–18.

Published

2015-05-26

How to Cite

Павшук, К. О. (2015). Right to resistance in the context of democratic processes. Problems of Legality, (129), 92–98. https://doi.org/10.21564/2414-990x.129.52031

Issue

Section

Constitutional and municipal law