Correction and resocialization of convicted persons on the territory of Ukraine in the XIX–XX centuries: theoretical and practical aspects
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.21564/2414-990X.153.229676Keywords:
correction and resocialization, historical aspect, correction and resocialization of convicts, demarcation, repressive and reorganization periods, correction and resocialization of the XIX–XX centuriesAbstract
The article is devoted to a step-by-step study aimed at reproducing the chain of historical events, peculiarities of the origin and primary legislative consolidation of the processes of correction and resocialization in the system of execution of criminal punishments on the territory of Ukraine. The authors set the goal to analyze not only the gradation of scientific and philosophical thought on the correction and resocialization of convicts in the XIX–XX centuries, but also to investigate the level of practical implementation of doctrinal provisions. The main historical events that influenced the development of correction and resocialization in the demarcation, repressive and reorganization periods of the history of Ukraine were outlined. Particular attention was paid to the analysis of regulations. The aim was to investigate not only the terminological component, but also the actual presence, because the resocialization of convicts existed long before its legislative consolidation in its modern form. To write the article, the authors used quotes from leading scholars of the period under study, statistics on the number of convicts in Ukraine in different periods of history, materials of public speeches of leading lawyers and a number of primary sources of historical significance.
It was found that in the XIX–XX centuries. correction and resocialization have gone through a difficult path of formation and further transformation. The formation of a modern approach to understanding these concepts was influenced by several complex reforms of the pre-revolutionary and Soviet periods, two world wars, a series of civil revolutions, the influence of about five separate state formations during political instability and destruction, periods of state formation, political usurpation with totalitarian regime. and a network of correctional labor camps, "thaw", complete Sovietization and a radical paradigm shift, which was associated with the improvement of domestic and foreign experience in the late twentieth century.
References
Antonyan, Yu.М. (2015). Penitenciarnaya periodizaciya i ispravlenie osuzhdennyh. II Mezhdunarodnyi penitenciarnyi forum – International Penitentiary Forum: sbornik tezisov vystuplenyi i dokladov uchasnikov. Ryazan, 4, 6–11 [in Russian].
Bandurka, A.M., Denysova, T.A., Trubnykov, V.M. (2002). Obschaya teoriya sotsialnoy adaptatsii osvobozhdennyih ot otbyivaniya nakazaniya. Kharkov-Zaporozhye [in Russian].
Vladimirskiy-Budanov, M.F. (1915). Obzor istorii russkogo prava. N.Ya. Ogloblin (Ed.). Kyiv [in Russian].
Kistyakovskiy, A.F. (1882). Elementarnyiy uchebnik obschego ugolovnogo prava s podrobnyim izlozheniem nachal russkogo ugolovnogo zakonodatelstva. Kiev: I. i A. Davidenko [in Russian].
Bogatyrev, I.H., Bohunov, S.O., Duka, O.A., Zinchenko, S.A., Kopotun, I.M., Freiman, H.O. (2013). Penitentsiarna systema Ukrainy: istoriia ta suchasnist: Vydannia do 15-oi richnytsi utvorennia tsentralnoho orhanu vykonavchoi vlady z pytan vykonannia pokaran. O.V. Lisitskov (Ed.). Kyiv: DPSU [in Ukrainian].
Goreglyad, O.I. (1815). Opyt nachertaniya rossiyskogo ugolovnogo prava. O prestupleniyah i nakazaniyah voobsche – About crimes and punishments in general. Sankt-Peterburg: Ios. Ioannesova. Part 1 [in Russian].
Palchenkova, V.M. (2013). Transformatsiia hromadskoho kontroliu za vykonanniam pokaran: istoryko-pravovyi analiz. Zaporizhzhia: Aktsent Invest-treid [in Ukrainian].
Badyra, V.A., Denysova, T.A. (2009). Pravovi osnovy vypravlennia ta resotsializatsii zhinok, zasudzhenykh do pozbavlennia voli. Zaporizhzhia [in Ukrainian].
Ivanyakov, R.I. (2019). Istoriya sozdaniya pervyih v Rossii uchrezhdeniy patronata nad osvobodivshimisya iz ispravitelnyih uchrezhdeniy. Vestnik sovremennoy nauki i praktiki – Bulletin of modern science and practice, 1, 18–21 [in Russian].
Ulozhenie o nakazaniyah ugolovnyih i ispravitelnyih: izdanie 1885 g. (1912). Svod zakonov Rossiyskoy imperii, Vol. 15. Sankt-Peterburg: Deyatel [in Russian].
Tagantsev, N.S. (1902). Russkoe ugolovnoe pravo. Vol. 2. Sankt-Peterburg: Gos. tip., 816–1460 [in Russian].
Sergeevskiy, N.D. (2008). Sovremennyie zadachi ugolovnogo zakonodatelstva v Rossii. Izbrannyie trudyi. A.I. Chuchaev (Ed.). Moscow [in Russian].
Bagriy-Shahmatov, L.V. (1976) Ugolovnaya otvetstvennost i nakazanie. Minsk: Vyisheysh. shk. [in Russian].
Kuchinskiy, I.A. (1897). K voprosu o nravstvennom ispravlenii prestupnikov. Zhurnal Ministerstva Yustitsii – Journal of the Ministry of Justice, 10, 147–158 [in Russian].
Foynitskiy, I.Ya. (1889). Uchenie o nakazanii v svyazi s tyurmovedeniem. Sankt-Peterburg: M-va putej soobshhenija (A. Benke) [in Russian].
Rossikhin, V.V. (2005). Penitentsiarna systema Rosiiskoi imperii v ХІХ – na pochatku ХХ st. (na materialakh ukrainskykh hubernii). Candidate’s thesis. Kharkiv [in Ukrainian].
Uporov, I.V. (2004). Penitencziarnaya politika Rossii v XVIII–XX vv. Istoriko-pravovoj analiz tendenczij razvitiya. Sankt-Peterburg: Yuridicheskij czentr press [in Russian].
Feldshtejn, G.S. (1893). Ssylka. Ocherki eya genezisa, znacheniya, istorii i sovremennogo sostoyaniya. Moskva: T-vo skoropechatni A.A. Levenson [in Russian].
Poznyshev, S.V. (1923). Osnovy` penitencziarnoj nauki. Moscow: Yuridicheskoe izdatel`stvo Narkomyusta [in Russian].
Grigor`ev, A.N. (1999). Reformirovanie penitencziarnoj sistemy` na Ukraine v koncze 19 – nachale 20 vv. na primere Tavricheskoj gubernii. Naukova elektronna biblioteka periodichnikh vidan NAN Ukrayini – Scientific electronic library of periodicals of the National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine, 1–8 [in Russian].
Malikov, B.Z. (2017). Stanovlenie ugolovno-ispolnitelnoy politiki v dorevolyutsionnoy i Sovetskoy Rossii. Ugolovno-ispolnitelnoe pravo – Penal law. Vol. 12, 4, 374–379 [in Russian].
Kovalevskiy, P.I. (1908). Borba s prestupnostyu putem vospitaniya. Moscow: t-va M.O. Volf [in Russian].
Gogel, S.K. (1906). Rol obschestva v dele borby s prestupnostyu. Sankt-Peterburg: Obschestvennaya polza [in Russian].
Vilenskiy-Sibiryakov, V.L. (1924). Katorga i ssylka v russkoy revolyutsii. Moscow: Vsesoyuznogo o-va politkatorzhan i ssyilnoposelentsev [in Russian].
Rybakov, A.A. (2015). Kontrol za litsami, uslovno-dosrochno osvobozhdennyimi ot otbyivaniya nakazaniya. Candidate’s thesis. Vladimir [in Russian].
Zakon ob uslovnom dosrochnom osvobozhdenii s izlozheniem rassuzhdeniy, na koih on osnovan (1909). D.A. Koptev (Ed.). Sankt-Peterburg: G.G. Hodunova [in Russian].
Yatsyshyn, M.M. (2010). Istoryko-pravovi zasady kryminalno-vykonavchoi polityky Ukrainy. Lutsk [in Ukrainian].
Potseluev, E.L. (2018). Ugolovno-pravovaya politika Vremennogo pravitelstva Rossii v 1917 godu. Vestnik Sankt-Peterburgskogo universiteta – Bulletin of St. Petersburg University, Vol. 9, 4–22. Sankt-Peterburg: Pravo [in Russian].
Petrogradskiy Sovet rabochih i soldatskih deputatov. Ispolnitelnyiy komitet. Protokolyi zasedaniy ispolnitelnogo komiteta i byuro I.K. (1925). B.Ya. Nalivayskyi (Ed.). Moscow: Gos. izd-vo [in Russian].
Zhizhilenko, A.A. (1923). Ocherki po obschemu ucheniyu o nakazanii. Petrograd: Academia [in Russian].
Utkin, V.A. (2017). Otechestvennaya nauka ugolovno-ispolnitelnogo prava: ocherk istorii. Ugolovnaya yustitsiya – Criminal justice, 9, 69–77 [in Russian].
Reent, Yu.A., Arhipov, S.V. (2017). Penitentsiarnaya sistema Rossii v usloviyah krizisa 1917 goda (k 100-letiyu Fevralskoy burzhuazno-demokraticheskoy revolyutsii v Rossii). Chelovek: prestuplenie i nakazanie – Human: crime and punishment.Vol. 26,. 2, 230–235 [in Russian].
Sokalska, O.V. (2018). Teoriia i istoriia derzhavy i prava; istoriia politychnykh i pravovykh uchen. Visnyk penitentsiarnoi asotsiatsii Ukrainy – Bulletin of Penitentiary Association of Ukraine. No. 3(5), 7–26 [in Ukrainian].
Dekret SNK No. 1 ot 24.11.1917 „O sude”. Sobranie uzakoneniy i rasporyazheniy pravitelstva za 1917–1918 gg. (1957). Moscow: Politizdat [in Russian].
Orel, Yu.V. (2015). Razvitie zakonodatelstva ob ugolovno-pravovoy ohrane normalnoy deyatelnosti organov i uchrezhdeniy penitentsiarnoy sluzhbyi Ukrainyi v 1917–1960 gg. Moscow: LEX RUSSICA, 7, 103–116 [in Russian].
Tokarev, Yu.S. (1963). Dokumentyi narodnyih sudov (1917–1922 gg.). Moscow: AN SSSR, 143–175 [in Russian].
Chuvakov, O.A. (2003). Kryminalne pravo v Ukraini (1917–1922 rr.). Candidate’s thesis. Odesa [in Ukrainian].
Ukrainska Tsentralna rada: Dokumenty i materialy: 4 bereznia – 9 hrudnia 1917 r. (Vols. 1–2); Vol. 1 (1996). V.F. Verstiuk (Ed.). NAN Ukrainy. Instytut istorii Ukrainy. Tsentralnyi derzhavnyi arkhiv vyshchykh orhaniv vlady i upravlinnia Ukrainy. Kyiv: Nauk. dumka [in Ukrainian].
Shirvindt, E.G., Utevskiy, B.S. (1927). Sovetskoe penitentsiarnoe pravo. Moscow [in Russian].
Radzinowicz, L. (1991). Penal Repressions. Cambridge Law Journal, 2, 422–444.
Podgorecki, A. (1996). Totalitarian Law: Basic Concepts and issues. Totalitarian and Post-Totalitarian Laws, 17
Kryminalno-vykonavche pravo Ukrainy (2018). (Vols. 1–2); Vol. 1. Ye.Yu. Barash (Ed.) Kyiv [in Ukrainian].
Fareniuk, S.Ia. (2002). Kryminalno-vykonavcha systema i zakonodavstvo politychnoho periodu. Kryminalno-vykonavche pravo Ukrainy – Penal law of Ukraine. O. M. Dzhudzhy (Ed.). Kyiv: Yurinkom Inter, 56–73 [in Ukrainian].
Shulhin, V.V. (2017). Realizatsiia viiskovoho zakonodavstva Ukrainy: teoretyko-pravovi aspekty. Candidate’s thesis. Kyiv [in Ukrainian].
Ukrainska Tsentralna rada: Dokumenty i materialy (Vols. 1–2); Vol. 2: 10 hrudnia 1917 r. – 29 kvitnia 1918 r. (1997). V.F. Verstiuk (Ed.). NAN Ukrainy. Instytut istorii Ukrainy. Tsentralnyi derzhavnyi arkhiv vyshchykh orhaniv vlady i upravlinnia Ukrainy. Kyiv: Nauk. dumka [in Ukrainian].
Hetman P.P. Skoropadskyi. Ukrayna na perelome. 1918 hod: Sbornyk dokumentov (2014). O.K. Yvantsova (Ed.). Moscow: Polytycheskaia entsyklopedyia [in Russian].
Manns, G.Yu. (1926). Obschee i spetsialnoe preduprezhdenie v ugolovnom prave. Irkutsk: Vlast truda [in Russian].
Hrestomatiya po istorii otechestvennogo gosudarstva i prava 1917-1991 godov (1997). Moscow: Zertsalo, 63–68 [in Russian].
Reent, Yu.A., Zhigalev, A.V. (2009). Stanovlenie ispravitelno-trudovoy sistemyi sovetskoy Rossii v 20-e godyi XX veka. Chelovek: prestuplenie i nakazanie – Human: crime and punishment, 2, 35–41 [in Russian].
Struchkov, N.A. (1984). Kurs ispravitelno-trudovogo prava. Problemy obschey chasti. Moscow: Yurid. Lit. [in Russian].
Kurskiy, D.I. (1958). Izbrannyie stati i rechi. Moscow: Gos. izd-vo yurid. lit-ryi [in Russian].
Shargorodskij, M.D. (1973). Nakazanie, ego czeli i effektivnost. Leningrad: Izd‑vo Leningr. un‑ta [in Russian].
Utkin, V.A. (1984). Nakazanie i ispravitelno-trudovoe vozdeystvie. Tomsk: izd-vo Tomsk. un-ta [in Russian].
Fumm, A.M., Yakovleva, O.N. (2016). Pervaya kodifikatsiya v sfere ispolneniya nakazaniy kak faktor razvitiya otechestvennogo ugolovno-ispolnitelnogo zakonodatelstva. Chelovek: prestuplenie i nakazanie – Human: crime and punishment,. 4, 41–45 [in Russian].
Ivan`kov, I.V. (2008). Rol i znachenie pervoy kodifikatsii ugolovnogo i ispravitelno-trudovogo zakonodatelstva Ukrainyi dlya organizatsionno-pravovyih osnov deyatelnosti organov i uchrezhdeniy ispolneniya nakazaniy. Vestnik instituta: prestuplenie, nakazanie, ispravlenie – Institute bulletin: crime, punishment, correction, 63–67 [in Russian].
Ot tyurem k vospitatelnyim uchrezhdeniyam: sbornik statey (1934). A.Ya. Vyishinskyi (Ed.). Moscow: Sovetskoe zakonodatelstvo. Vol. 1. [in Russian].
Zasoby vypravlennia i resotsializatsii zasudzhenykh do pozbavlennia voli (2011). A. H. Stepaniuk (Ed.). Kharkiv [in Ukrainian].
Uporov, I.V. (2017). Ispravitelno-trudovoy kodeks RSFSR 1933 g.: obschepravovaya harakteristika. Gumanitarnyiy nauchnyiy vestnik – Humanitarian scientific bulletin, 10, 6–11 [in Russian].
Smyikalin, A.S. (2016). Kolonii i tyurmy v sovetskoy Rossii. Moscow: Yustitsiya [in Russian].
Saltyk, G.A.(2012) Vospominaniya byivshih uznikov ispravitelno-trudovyih lagerey SSSR kak istoricheskiy istochnik. Elektronnyiy nauchnyiy zhurnal Kurskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta, 4, 16–20.
Utevskiy, B.S. (1935). Sovetskaya ispravitelno-trudovaya politika. Moscow: OGIZ [in Russian].
Suslina, E.V. (2016). Ponimanie lisheniya svobodyi v trudah M.M. Isaeva i B.S. Utevskogo. Aktualnyie problemyi rossiyskogo prava – Actual problems of Russian law, 12(73), 220–226 [in Russian].
Ivanova, G.M. (2006). Istoriya GULAGa, 1918–1958: sotsialno-ekonomicheskiy i politiko-pravovoy aspektyi. Moscow: Nauka [in Russian].
Hohlov, A.V. (2009). Rol sektora "lagernoy" ekonomiki v vosstanovlenii narodnogo hozyaystva: problemyi istoriografii. Nauchnye vedomosti BelGU – Scientific bulletin of BelSU, 15(70), 170–175 [in Russian].
Smirnov, L.B., Ocheredko, V.P. (2005). Penitentsiarnaya sistema sovetskogo gosudarstva v predvoennyie i voennyie godyi (1930–1945 gg.) i ee rol v dostizhenii pobedyi v Velikoy Otechestvennoy voyne 1941–1945 gg. Vestnik Sankt-Peterburgskogo universiteta MVD Rossii – Bulletin of the St. Petersburg University of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia. No. 2, 61–66 [in Russian].
Ashin, A.A. (2008). Vospitatelnaya koloniya: istoriya i sovremennost. Vladimir: Vladim. gos. un-t [in Russian].
Smyikalin, A.S. (2020). Neizvestnyie stranitsyi istorii penitentsiarnoy sistemyi SSSR (k 75-letiyu pobedyi v Velikoy Otechestvennoy voyne 1941–1945 gg.). Vestnik Uralskogo yuridicheskogo instituta MVD Rossii – Bulletin of the Ural Law Institute of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia, 1, 89–93 [in Russian].
Kudoyarova, G.R. (2020). K voprosu o resotsializatsii spetskontingenta sovetskoy penitentsiarnoy sistemyi v godyi Velikoy Otechestvennoy voynyi. Vestnik Uralskogo yuridicheskogo instituta MVD Rossii – Bulletin of the Ural Law Institute of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia, 4, 149–153 [in Russian].
Kristi, N. (2001). Borba s prestupnostyu kak industriya. Vpered, k Gulagu zapadnogo obraztsa. Moscow: ROO «Tsentr sodeystviya reforme ugolovnogo pravosudiya» [in Russian].
Rossikhin, V.V. (2013). Stan ta zminy penitentsiarnoi systemy URSR u 1950–ti rr. Visnyk Kharkivskoho natsionalnoho universytetu vnutrishnikh sprav – Bulletin of Kharkiv National University of Internal Affairs, 4, 29–37 [in Ukrainian].
Reabilitatsiia represovanykh: zakonodavstvo ta sudova praktyka (1997). V. T. Maliarenko (Ed.). Kyiv: Yurinkom [in Ukrainian].
Zasedaniya Verhovnogo Soveta SSSR 5-go sozyiva (22–25 dekabrya 1958 g.): stenograficheskiy otchet. (1959) [in Russian].
Lelental, S. (1967). Wychowawczy cel kary. Zeszyty naukowe uniwersytetu Lodzkiego – Scientific journals of the University of Lodz, 172–173 [in Polish].
Ob utverzhdenii Osnov ugolovnogo zakonodatelstva Soyuza SSR i soyuznyih respublik: Zakon SSSR ot 25.12.1958 (1959). Vedomosti Verhovnogo Soveta SSSR – Bulletin of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR, 1–24 [in Russian].
Noy, I.S. (1973). Suschnost i funktsii ugolovnogo nakazaniya v sovetskom gosudarstve. Saratov: izdatelstvo Sarat. un-ta [in Russian].
Yakovlev, A.M. (1964). Borba s retsidivnoy prestupnostyu. A. A. Piontkovskogo (Ed.). Moscow: Nauka [in Russian].
Belyaev, N.A. (1963). Tseli nakazaniya i sredstva ih dostizheniya v ispravitelno-trudovyih uchrezhdeniyah. Leningrad: Izd-vo Leningr. un-ta [in Russian].
Lyozina, E.V. (2017). VChK i ee preemniki: metodyi terrora i praktiki diskriminatsii k 100-letiyu osnovaniya sovetskoy taynoy politsii. Vestnik obschestvennogo mneniya, 3–4 (125), 104–131.
Vypravno-trudovyi kodeks: Zakon SRSR vid 23.12.1970 r. № 3325-VII v redaktsii vid 05.06.2003. URL: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/3325-07.
Orlov, V.N. (2018). Idei professora N.A. Struchkova i perspektivyi razvitiya ugolovno-ispolnitelnogo prava. Ugolovno-ispolnitelnoe pravo – Penal Law, Vol. 13(1–4), 1, 8–13 [in Russian].
Sharkov, A.V. (2018). Stanovlenie i razvitie nauki ispravitelno-trudovogo prava sovetskogo gosudarstva (1956–1991 gg.), 290–293 [in Russian].
Kryminalno-vykonavche pravo. Slovnyk-dovidnyk (2020). S.F. Denysov (Ed.). Chernihiv: Desna Polihraf [in Ukrainian].
Radov, H.O. (1997). Doktrynalna model zakonu “Pro penitentsiarnu systemu Ukrainy”. Problemy penitentsiarnoi teorii i praktyky – Problems of penitentiary theory and practice. Kyiv, 11–53 [in Ukrainian].
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2021 Denysov S. F., Zaika D. Ye.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
