Borders of use criminalistics and medical knowledge in crime investigation

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.21564/2414-990x.142.139928

Keywords:

criminalistics, criminalistic knowledge, medical sciences, criminalistic medicine, medical traosology, medical and criminalistic examinations, medical and criminalistic identification

Abstract

The article studies of the issues related to usage of criminalistic and medical knowledge in criminal proceedings. I have singled out the forms of their usage including separate or parallel usage, interaction and mutual borrowing of individual techniques and methods.

Today, criminalistics is actively developing as a science, with its theoretical wing going particularly strong. Scientists come up with new concepts, certain provisions or theories. However, I believe that the currently attention is partially shifted from the issues related to usage of  criminalistic knowledge and their place in the system of modern scientific knowledge in various spheres. This is especially true in cases when criminalistic knowledge has to be explored in connection with the modern medical knowledge. Although the following scholars studied the issues related to usage of criminalistic knowledge: R. S. Belkin, V. A. Zhuravel, N. I. Klymenko, V. Yu. Shepitko and others. Нowever, their works do not touch heavily upon the connection between usage of criminalistic knowledge in criminal proceedings simultaneously with expertise in other scientific areas, particularly, Medicine. Thus, the purpose of the article is to outline the extent of usage of  criminalistic  and medical knowledge in crime investigation. For example, criminalistic and medical knowledge may be used in criminal proceedings in a variety of ways. It may be used separately or in parallel, in interaction or interconnection. The mutual interaction between these two areas of knowledge have given birth to a variety of branches of science including “criminalistic medicine”, “medical traosology”, “medical and criminalistic examinations” and “medical and  criminalistic identification”.

Author Biography

Вікторія Олегівна Яремчук, Yaroslav Mudryi National Law University

PhD in Law, Assistant at the Department of Criminalistics

References

Avdeev, M.I. (1959). Kurs sudebnoj mediciny. Moscow: Gosjurizdat [in Russian].

Belkin, R.S. (2001). Kurs kriminalistiki.Moscow: JuNITI-DANA: Zakon i pravo [in Russian].

Bokarius,N.S.(1915). Sudebnaja medicina v izlozhenii dlja juristov: opyt izlozhenija osnov sudebnoj mediciny dlja juristov.Kharkov: Tipografija i litografija M. Zil'berberga i S-v'ja [in Russian].

Voprosy sudebnoj travmatologii: mezhved. sbornik. A. M. Gamburg (Ed.). (1969).Kiev: Zdorov'ja, 2, 216 [in Russian].

Danshyn, M.V. (2013). Kryminalistyka XXI stolittia: mistse u systemi naukovoho znannia. Kharkiv [in Ukrainian].

Zhuravel, V.A. (2016). Mizhnaukovi zviazky kryminalistyky. Vybrani tvory – Іzbrannye trudу. Kharkiv: Apostil, 52–61 [in Ukrainian].

Klimenko, N.I., Kirichenko, A.A. (1994). Kriminalistika kak nauka i uchebnaja disciplina. Dnіpropetrovs'k [in Russian].

Knobloh, Je. (1960). Medicinskaja kriminalistika. Praga: Gos. izdatel'stvo medicinskoj literatury [in Russian].

Korneev, V.A. Ivanov, V.K. (1990). Zadachi i vozmozhnosti spektral'nyh issledovanij ob#ektov sudebno-medicinskoj i kriminalisticheskoj jekspertizy. Aktual'nyj voprosy sudebnoj mediciny, 139–142 [in Russian].

Kostenko, K.I., Nefedova, T.K., Asaf'eva, N.I. (1969). Vyjavlenie ustojchivosti i izmenjaemosti priznakov pocherka v zavisimosti ot stepeni alkogol'nogo op'janenija. Voprosy sudebnoj mediciny.Saratov, 4, 84–87 [in Russian].

Lozovyi, A.I., Derecha, L.M., Miasoiedov, V.V. et al. (2015). Optymizatsiia mizhvidomchoi vzaiemodii sudovo-ekspertnykh ustanov Ministerstva yustytsii ta Ministerstva okhorony zdorov’ia Ukrainy pry zdiisnenni sudovo-ekspertnoi diialnosti Teoriia ta praktyka sudovoi ekspertyzy i kryminalistyky. Kharkiv: Pravo, 15, 395–404 [in Ukrainian].

Mediko-kriminalisticheskaja identifikacija: (2000). nastolnaja kniga sudebno-medicinskogo jeksperta. V. V. Tomilin (Ed.).Moscow, NORMA INFRA-M [in Russian].

Morhun, A.O., Khyzhniak, V.V., Litkevych, N.S.et al.(2017). Normatyvna novela shchodo ohliadu trupa na mistsi podii. Aktualni pytannia sudovoi ekspertyzy ta kryminalistyky: Proceedings of the Conference Title (Kharkiv, 7-8 lystop. 2017r). KhNDI sudov. ekspertyz im. M. S. Bokariusa [in Ukrainian].

Praktykum z kursu «Sudova medytsyna» [in Ukrainian].

Sapozhnikov, Ju.S. (1970). Kriminalistika v sudebnoj medicine. Kiev: Zdorov'e [in Russian]

Sudebnaja medicina. (1987). V. V. Tomilin (Ed.).Moscow: Juridicheskaja literature [in Russian].

Sudova medytsyna (2016). O. I. Herasymenko (Ed.). Kyiv: KNT [in Ukrainian].

Sudovo-medychna kryminalistyka (2013). O. V. Fylypchuka O. M. Hurovoi (Eds.). Kharkiv: Disa plius [in Ukrainian].

Chornous, Yu.M. (2017). Kryminalistychne zabezpechennia rozsliduvannia zlochyniv. Vinnytsia: TOV Nilan-LTD [in Ukrainian].

Shepitko, V.Yu. (2016). Vstup do navchalnoho kursu "Kryminalistyka". Kyiv: In Yure [in Ukrainian].

Shikanov, V.I. (1975). Informacija k takticheskoj operacii "Atribucija trupa". Irkutsk: Izdatel'stvo Irkutskogo universiteta [in Russian].

Charles, R. Swanson, Neil C. Chamelin, Leonard Territo et al. (2000). Criminal investigation. 7th ed. Boston: Mcgraw–hill [in English].

Crime and Criminology. (2000). edited by Sue Titus Reid. 9 th. ed.Florida:FloridaStateUniversity[in English].

Forensic medicine. (2017). edited by B. V. Mykhailychenko. Kyiv. Aus Medicine Publising [in English].

Kriminalistik und forensisce Wissenschatten. (1974).Berlin. VEB Deutscher Verlad der Wissenschften. 14, 114 [in German].

Reimann, W., Prokop, О., Geserick, G. (1990). Gerichts Medizin. Vademecum. Berlin: Verlag Gesundheit GmbH [in German].

Role of Forensic expert institutions in the prevention of and in combatting crime in Ukraine(2013). The legal system of Ukraine: past, present, and future. Volume V. General edition V. V. Stashis. Kyiv, Kharkiv: Law ofUkraine, Pravo [in English].

Shepitko, V.Yu. (2011). The function of crime investigation and certain tendencies of criminalistics. A First Printed Criminalist: International Research and Practice Juridical Journal. Kharkiv: Apostille Publishing House LLC, 2, 50–55 [in English].

Tadeusz Marcinkowski (1982). Medycyna sadova dla prawnikow. Warszawa: Wydawnictwo Prawnicze [in Polish].

Published

2018-10-04

How to Cite

Яремчук, В. О. (2018). Borders of use criminalistics and medical knowledge in crime investigation. Problems of Legality, (142), 211–219. https://doi.org/10.21564/2414-990x.142.139928

Issue

Section

CRIMINAL PROCEDURE AND СRIMINALISTICS