Formation of ecological and legal science: resource aspect and its integration problems

Authors

  • А. П. Гетьман Yaroslav Mudryi National Law University, Ukraine https://orcid.org/0000-0002-1987-2760
  • Віталій Анатолійович Зуєв Academy of Customs Service of Ukraine, Ukraine

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.21564/2414-990x.132.63175

Keywords:

environmental law, natural-resource law, natural resources, environmental resources, ecological and legal science

Abstract

Problem setting. Social and environmental issues of waste management facing society relatively recently, but showed a tendency to expand and deepen, which in turn caused the necessity of formation of effective policy in this area.

Recent research and publications analysis. Some aspects of the present stage of the formation of environmental law and its relationship to nature and resources law, structural and systemic connections was studied by various researchers in the context of environmental policy and legislation analysis, regulation of wildlife relationships, expanding the scope of regulation of resource. In particular, they can mark out V. Andreytsev, A. Getman, M. Krasnova, N. Malisheva and others. However, comprehensive studies of this policy is currently not available.

Paper objective. The purpose of the article is a theoretical analysis of the current state of environmental law, the formation of the next stage of development of natural resource relationships, their expansion and transformation into a resource (ecologic and resource) in order to adequately respond to the differentiation and complexity of structural and systemic linkages.

Paper main body. The development and dynamics of the environmental, natural resources legislation is largely driven by global and European processes and requires constant updating in order to overcome gaps, timely and adequate response to contemporary challenges, changes in value paradigms and so forth. One of these problems is the development of traditional branches of law and directions research that, in turn, raises the question of substantive content, structural and systemic links of these areas of law. Any delay in the establishment of the theoretical and methodological and scientific and legal framework for a new legal phenomena in the framework of ecological and legal science creates the preconditions for the expansion of research not only to them but also in relation to the already well-established system of law and the separation of the industry.

A promising seems the further transformation of natural resource rights in the resource, whose task will be to not only relations concerning those or other natural objects, but also the products of their use, and natural phenomena, the establishment of resource-saving requirements, the introduction of specific indicators of resource costs and the like. Such a situation we are seeing now in soil legislation, which regulates the use of man-made mineral deposits, which, in fact, lost the status of a natural object, but are important for their conservation. A similar situation arises in the field of waste management, which are increasingly seen it as a potential source of resources and nature conservation.

It is proved that with the current approach, when the subject and its activity are taken as a basis for regulation in isolation from the goals of legal regulation, the values and ideological component of the legal regulation, which had a negative impact on its quality are lost. It should be pointed out that in many cases such restrictions are connected with artificial internal limits of innovations of eco-legal science, caused by the use of the traditional concepts of “nature”, “natural resources”, “natural objects”. This causes an urgent need to review the use of these terms, the expansion of concepts. One way to become more active use of the terms “resource use, “eco use”, “resources”, “environmental resources”, “environmental objects” and so forth.

Conclusions of the research. Stage of relatively independent existence of natural resource law, its autonomy outside the complex ecological and legal science has already passed and now destructively affects both its development in general and on the development of its constituent elements, slows its methodological development, creates the prerequisites for scientific expansion of specialists in other sectors of law that use internal scientific debate and controversy as a confirmation of their own conclusions about the artificial synthesized nature of environmental law, artificiality of scientific problems and so on. One of the ways to integrate and harmonize the natural resource component within the environmental law is to change its focus from solely having binding traditional natural objects in favor of a more progressive and promising theory of the resource or the ecological and resource rights that can harmoniously incorporate both traditional (established), and innovative approaches to the maintenance of ecological and legal relations, their expansion and diffusion within a single methodological approach and legal doctrine, which is the fundamental goal of ecological and legal science, defined as the environment, the use of environmental resources and ecological security of humanity.

 

 

Author Biographies

А. П. Гетьман, Yaroslav Mudryi National Law University

Doctor of Law, Professor

Academician of the National Academy of Legal Sciences of Ukraine

Vice-Rector

Department of Environmental Law

 

Scopus Profile: link

Profile Google Scholar: link

ID ORCID: http://orcid.org/0000-0002-1987-2760

 

Selected Publications:

1. Гетьман, А. П. Державно-правові проблеми подолання екологічної кризи в епоху глобалізації / А. П. Гетьман, В. І. Лозо // Проблеми законності. – Харків, 2013. – Вип. 123. – С. 65–77. 

2. Гетьман, А. П. Доктрина науки екологічного права: генеза теоретичних досліджень еколого-правових проблем у XX ст. / А. П. Гетьман // Право України. – 2014. – № 12. – С. 143–154.

3. Гетьман, А. П. Екологічні права людини в національній і міжнародній правовій доктрині / А. П. Гетьман, В. В. Костицький // Проблеми законності. – Харків, 2013. – Вип. 124. – С. 68–80.

4. Гетьман, А. П. Екологічна функція держави в сучасних глобалізаційних процесах / А. П. Гетьман // Проблеми законності. – Харків, 2015. – Вип. 128. – С. 145–153.

5. Гетьман, А. П. Концепция развития экологического права и законодательства как предпосылка обеспечения национальной экологической политики / А. Гетьман // Ежегодник украинского права. – Харьков : Право, 2014. – № 6. – С. 465–474.

6. Гетьман, А. П. Методологічні засади становлення правових основ охорони довкілля / А. Гетьман // Право України. – 2011. – № 2. – С. 11–19.

7. Гетьман, А. П. Організаційно-правовий механізм охорони навколишнього природного середовища / А. П. Гетьман // Проблеми законності. – Харків, 2014. – Вип. 125. – С. 119–128.

8. Гетьман, А. П. Процессуальные нормы и отношения в экологическом праве / А. П. Гетьман. – Харьков : Основа, 1994. – 136 с.

9. Гетьман, А. П. Регіональний екологічний контроль: теорія правового регулювання : моногр. / А. П. Гетьман, Л. М. Здоровко. – Київ : Ін-т законод. передбачень і прав. експертизи, 2004. – 216 с.

10. Гетьман, А. П. Тридцать лет с экологическим правом : [автобиогр. : избр. тр.] / А. П. Гетьман. – Харьков : Кроссроуд, 2013. – 284 с.

11. Гетьман, А. П. Эколого-правовые договоры: законодательная ретроспектива и современность / А. Гетьман // Ежегодник украинского права. – Харьков : Право, 2013. – № 5. – С. 409–427.

12. Правова охорона довкілля: сучасний стан та перспективи розвитку : моногр. / Нац. юрид. ун-т ім. Ярослава Мудрого ; за ред. А. П. Гетьмана. – Харків : Право, 2014. – 784 с. – (Харківська наукова школа екологічного права).

13. Правове виховання в сучасній Україні : моногр. / Нац. юрид. акад. України ім. Ярослава Мудрого ; за заг. ред.: В. Тацій, А. Гетьман, О. Г. Данильян. – 2-ге вид., переробл. і допов. – Харків : Право, 2013. – 440 с.

14. Правове регулювання екологічних, аграрних та земельних відносин в Україні: сучасний стан і напрями вдосконалення : моногр. / Нац. ун-т "Юрид. акад. України ім. Ярослава Мудрого", НДІ правознавства ; за ред.: А. П. Гетьман, В. Ю. Уркевич. – Харків : Право, 2012. – 448 с.

Віталій Анатолійович Зуєв, Academy of Customs Service of Ukraine

Assoc. Prof., head of civil law courses department

References

Mykolenko, O.I. (2012). Sub"yektyvni faktory, yaki nehatyvno vplyvayut' na rozvytok nauky administratyvnoho prava [Subjective factors affecting the development of science of administrative law]. Aktual'ni problemy derzhavy i prava – Actual problems of law, 68, 453–458 [in Ukrainian].

Get'man, A.P. (2009). Vytoky nauky ekolohichnoho prava Ukrayiny [The origins of the science of environmental law Ukraine]. Problemy zakonnosti / nauk. red. V.Ya. Tatsiy – Problems of legality. V.Ya. Tatsiy (Eds.), 100, 165–175 [in Ukrainian]; Getman, A. P. (2010). Geneza nauky ekologichnogo prava: istorychnyj aspekt [Genesis of Environmental Law Science: a historical aspect]. Actual Problems of Reforming of Land, Environmental, Agricultural and Economic Relations in Ukraine. Hmel'nyc'kyj: Vydavnyctvo Hmel'nyc'kogo un-ta upravlinnja ta prava, 196-199 [in Ukrainian]; Get'man, A.P. (2010). Retrospektyva rozvytku ekolohichnoyi pravovoyi nauky [Retrospective of environmental jurisprudence]. Derzhava i pravo u svitli suchasnoyi yurydychnoyi dumky. Kyiv: Yuryd. dumka, 342–347 [in Ukrainian]; Get'man, A.P. (2012). Vytoky ekolohichnoho zakonodavstva v naukovykh pratsyakh uchenykh-yurystiv [The origins of environmental legislation in the scientific works of scientists, lawyers]. Byuleten' Ministerstva yustytsiyi Ukrayiny, 11 (133), 38–43 [in Ukrainian]; Get'man, A.P. (2014). Doktryna nauky ekolohichnoho prava: geneza teoretychnykh doslidzhen' ekoloho-pravovykh problem u XX st. [Doctrine of Science Environmental Law: Genesis theoretical studies environmental and legal issues in the XX century]. Pravo Ukrayiny, 12, 143–154 [in Ukrainian]; Getman, A. (2016). Environmental and legal science: current state and prospects of development. Yearbook of Ukrainian law. O.V. Petryshyn (Ed.), 8, 259–267 [in Ukrainian].

Orendarets', O.O. (2015). Rozvytok nauky ekolohichnoho prava [The development of science of environmental law]. Extended abstract of candidate’s thesis. Kyiv [in Ukrainian].

Lloyd, D. (2009). Ideya prava [The right idea]. (M.A. Yumasheva Trans.). Yu.M. Yumashev (Ed.). 5d ed. Moskva: Knigodel [in Ukrainian].

Pasporty spetsial'nostey (2009): zatv. postanovoyu prezydiyi VAK Ukrayiny vid 8 zhovt. 2008 N 45-06/7 / Atestatsiynyy protses: normatyvna baza [Passport of spetsіalitys]. Byuleten' VAK Ukrayiny, 1, 6–19 [in Ukrainian].

Gorodov, O.A. (2015). Vvedenie v energeticheskoe pravo [Introduction to the energy law]. – Moscow: Prospekt [in Russian].

Balyuk, H.I., Koval'chuk T.H., Sushyk O.V. (2012). Enerhetychne pravo Ukrayiny. Modul' 1: Enerhetychne pravo Ukrayiny. Ekoloho-pravovi problemy v enerhetytsi: robocha navch. prohrama [Energy Law Ukraine. Module 1: Energy Law Ukraine. Ecological and legal problems in the energy sector: Working teach. program]. Kyiv: Kyiv. nats. un-t im. Tarasa Shevchenka [in Ukrainian].

Kostryukov, S.V. (2015). Navchal'no-metodychne zabezpechennya dystsypliny «Enerhetychne pravo» [Educational and methodical discipline "Energy Law"]. Dnipropetrovs'k: NHU [in Ukrainian].

Mel'nyk, R.S. (2010). Systema administratyvnoho prava Ukrayiny [The system of administrative law Ukraine]. Extended abstract of doctor’s thesis. Kharkiv: Khark. nats. un-t vnutr. sprav [in Ukrainian].

Dzhumahel'diyeva, H.D. (2014). Pravove rehulyuvannya hospodars'koho vykorystannya pryrodnykh resursiv [Legal regulation of economic use of natural resources]. Kyiv: Yuryd. dumka [in Ukrainian].

Bevzenko, V.M. (2015). Administratyvno-zemel'ne pravo Ukrayiny [Administrative and Land Law Ukraine]. Kyiv: Alerta [in Ukrainian].

Yureskul, V.O. (2014). Shchodo podatku na atmosferni opady [As for the tax on precipitation]. Pravove zhyttya suchasnoyi Ukrayiny: materialy mizhnar. nauk.-prakt. konf., prysvyachenoyi yuvileyu akad. S.V. Kivalova (16-17 trav. 2014, m. Odesa), vols. 1-2, vol. 2. V.M. Dryomin (Ed.)]. Odesa: Yuryd. l-ra, 511-513 [in Ukrainian].

Andreytsev, V.I. (2015). Perspektyvy rozvytku pryrodoresursovoho prava v systemi ekolohichnoho prava Ukrayiny [Prospects pryrodnoresursovoho law system of environmental law Ukraine]. Pryrodoresursne pravo v systemi prava Ukrayiny: istoriya, s'ohodennya, perspektyvy : zb. materialiv kruhloho stolu, 30-31 zhovt. 2015. M. Shulga (Ed.). Kharkiv: Oberih, 8–12 [in Ukrainian].

Malysheva, N.R. (2015). U pryrodoresursnoho prava mayut' nareshti z"yavytys' kryla [In natural resource rights have finally emerged wings]. Pryrodoresursne pravo v systemi prava Ukrayiny: istoriya, s'ohodennya, perspektyvy: zb. materialiv kruhloho stolu, 30-31 zhovt. 2015. M. Shulga (Ed.). Kharkiv: Oberih, 132–134 [in Ukrainian].

Yermolenko, V.M. (2015). Pryrodoresursne pravo v systemi prava Ukrayiny / V. M. Yermolenko [Natural resource law in the law Ukraine]. Pryrodoresursne pravo v systemi prava Ukrayiny: istoriya, s'ohodennya, perspektyvy: zb. materialiv kruhloho stolu, 30-31 zhovt. 2015. M. Shulga (Ed.). Kharkiv: Oberih, 65–67 [in Ukrainian].

Bavbekova, E.A., Bondar, L.O., Havrysh, N.S. et al. (2005). Pryrodoresursove pravo Ukrayiny [Еnvironmental legal science of Ukraine]. I.I. Karakash (Ed.). Kyiv: Istyna [in Ukrainian].

Karakash, I.I. (2015). Shchodo pryntsypiv suchasnoho pryrodoresursovoho prava Ukrayiny [As for the principles of modern law pryrodnoresursovoho Ukraine]. Pryrodoresursne pravo v systemi prava Ukrayiny: istoriya, s'ohodennya, perspektyvy: zb. materialiv kruhloho stolu, 30-31 zhovt. 2015. M. Shulga (Ed.). Kharkiv: Oberih, 79–82 [in Ukrainian].

Kulynych, P.F. (2015). Pryrodoresursne pravo yak yurydychnyy fenomen: polemichni aspekty [Natural resource law as a legal phenomenon: the polemical aspects]. Pryrodoresursne pravo v systemi prava Ukrayiny: istoriya, s'ohodennya, perspektyvy: zb. materialiv kruhloho stolu, 30-31 zhovt. 2015. M. Shulga (Ed.). Kharkiv: Oberih, 111–113 [in Ukrainian].

Krasnova, M.V. (2015). Suchasni realiyi pryrodoresursnoho prava Ukrayiny / M. V. Krasnova [Modern realities of natural resource law Ukraine]. Pryrodoresursne pravo v systemi prava Ukrayiny: istoriya, s'ohodennya, perspektyvy: zb. materialiv kruhloho stolu, 30-31 zhovt. 2015. M. Shulga (Ed.). Kharkiv: Oberih, 111–113 [in Ukrainian].

Shul'ha, M.V., Leyba L.V. (2015). Do pytannya pro pryrodoresursove pravo [On the Law pryrodnoresursove]. / M. V. Shul'ha, // Pryrodoresursne pravo v systemi prava Ukrayiny: istoriya, s'ohodennya, perspektyvy: zb. materialiv kruhloho stolu, 30-31 zhovt. 2015. M. Shulga (Ed.). Kharkiv: Oberih, 208–211. [in Ukrainian].

Kazantsev, N.D. (1967). Prirodnoresursovoe pravo i ego predelyi kak integrirovannoy otrasli prava [Natural resource law and its limits with an integrated industry law]. Vestnik Moskovskogo universiteta. Seriya 10 «Pravo», 6, 3–9 [in Russian].

Malyisheva, N., Nepyiyvoda V. (2007). Sootnoshenie prirodoresursnogo prava i prava okruzhayuschey sredyi: novyiy vzglyad na staruyu problemu [The ratio of natural resource rights and environmental law: a new look at an old problem]. Gosudarstvo i pravo, 9, 31–40 [in Russian].

Get'man, A.P. (2014). Kontseptsiya rozvytku ekolohichnoho prava ta zakonodavstva yak peredumova zabezpechennya natsional'noyi ekolohichnoyi polityky [The concept of environmental law and legislation as a precondition for the national environmental policy]. Visnyk Pivdennoho rehional'noho tsentru Natsional'noyi akademiyi pravovykh nauk Ukrayiny, 1,. 107–114 [in Ukrainian].

Kalynyn, Y.B. (2001). Pravovoe rehulyrovanye resursopol'zovanyya [Legal regulation of resource use]. Tomsk: Yzd-vo nauch.-tekh. lyt. [in Russian].

Hunyan, L. (2010). Kontsept i vzglyadyi na prirodu v ekologicheskom prave [Conceived and views of nature in environmental law]. Gosudarstvo i pravo, 3, 90–99 [in Russian].

Krasnova, M.V. (2012). Metodolohichni zasady suchasnoho ekolohichnoho prava [Methodological principles of modern environmental law]. Visnyk Kyyivs'koho natsional'noho universytetu imeni Tarasa Shevchenka. Yurydychni nauky, 92, 5–8 [in Ukrainian].

Reymers, N.F. (1994). Ekologiya (teorii, zakonyi, pravila, printsipyi i gipotezyi) [Ecology (theories, laws, rules, principles and hypotheses)]. Moscow: Rossiya Molodaya [in Russian].

Andrushkiv B.M., Vovk Yu.Ya., Vovk I.P. et al. (2012). Resursonomika: teoretychni ta prykladni aspekty [Resursonomika: theoretical and applied aspects]. – Ternopil': Ternohraf [in Ukrainian].

Kokorin A.O. (Ed.). (2004). Parnikovyie gazyi – globalnyiy ekologicheskiy resurs: spravochnik [Greenhouse gases – global environmental resource]. Moscow: WWF Rossiya [in Russian].

Planning for sustainable use of land resources: towards a new approach. (1995). Land and water bulletin of the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations, 2.

Sostoyanie okruzhayuschey sredyi i vklad Programmyi Organizatsii Ob'edinennyih Natsiy po okruzhayuschey srede v reshenie osnovnyih ekologicheskih problem [State of the environment and contribution of the United Nations Programme on Environment in addressing substantive environmental challenges]: doklad Direktora-ispolnitelya Soveta upravlyayuschih Programmyi Organizatsii Ob'edinennyih Natsiy po okruzhayuschey srede: dokument UNEP/GC.23/3/. Retrived from: http://www.unep.org/GC/GC23/documents/GC23-3-Russian.pdf [in Russian].

Zuеv, V.A., Shmidt M., Hansmann et al. (2015). Pravovoe regulirovanie obrascheniya s othodami [Legal regulation of waste management]. Upravlenie ustoychivyim razvitiem v usloviyah perehodnoy ekonomiki. Dnepropetrovsk-Kottbus: NGU – BTU, 118–128 [in Russian]; Zuev, V.A. (2014). Pravovyie problemyi formirovaniya prava obrascheniya s othodami i napravleniya sistematizatsii zakonodatelstva v dannoy sfere v natsionalnom zakonodatelstve [Legal problems of formation of the right waste management and direction of systematization of legislation in this area in the national legislation]. Legea si Viata. Sept., 50–53 [in Russian]; Zuev, V.A. (2015). Vid pryrodoresursnoho do resursnoho prava: otsinka perspektyv ta potentsialu [From natural resource to resource rights: grade prospects and potential]. Pryrodoresursne pravo v systemi prava Ukrayiny: istoriya, s'ohodennya, perspektyvy: zb. materialiv kruhloho stolu, 30-31 zhovt. 2015. M. Shulga (Ed.). Kharkiv: Oberih, 154-156 [in Ukrainian].

Published

2016-04-20

How to Cite

Гетьман, А. П., & Зуєв, В. А. (2016). Formation of ecological and legal science: resource aspect and its integration problems. Problems of Legality, (132), 104–123. https://doi.org/10.21564/2414-990x.132.63175

Issue

Section

Environmental and administrative law